Research
Natural mixing
What makes two paints on a screen combine the way two real ones do?
Two halves
- What color two paints make. Averaging screen colors turns blue and yellow into grey, the surest sign of fake paint. Real pigments mix subtractively: each absorbs and scatters light, and the Kubelka–Munk model describes how a mix of them reflects it.
- Where, and how unevenly, they mix. Real paint marbles, streaks, dirties the brush and tints the next stroke. A mixer that blends evenly and instantly feels fake even when its colors are right.
Most apps do only the first, if that.
Why real pigments, not colors
Modelling each color as a named pigment, with its own absorption and scattering across the spectrum, makes the behaviour painters know come out of the physics instead of being faked: titanium white covers, ochre is gentle and earthy, ultramarine and an earth red make near-blacks, and blue and yellow make green. Open alternatives exist (Mixbox, Spectral.js), but a fixed set of real pigments is the most faithful, and it lets a mix be written as a recipe of parts.
Why it should stay uneven
- Paint is carried more than it is blended, so a color dragged through another marbles for several passes before it turns even.
- The brush picks up as it lays down. A stroke's tail carries the color it passed through, the dirty-brush streak, with nothing authored.
- Side-by-side strokes mix in the eye, as in Impressionist broken color, so the engine must not over-blend.
- Mud is honest. Too many pigments together make brown, in oils as in the app. Limited palettes such as Anders Zorn's (white, ochre, red and black) teach mixing without mud.
What Enogu does
Every spot on the canvas holds amounts of real pigments, not a color: up to eight of the fifteen in the palette, and a mix holds up to eight. They mix by Kubelka–Munk across the spectrum, checked against real paint swatches. Brushes carry paint on their hairs, pick up wet paint as they go and tint the next stroke or two, so colors marble and streak. Your mixes are recipes in parts, and each pigment sits once in the color ring, beside its relatives.