Research
Depth and light
What makes paint on a screen read as a surface lit from somewhere, one that changes as you turn the phone, rather than a photo of paint?
Depth is mostly light
A perfect height map under a flat, fixed light looks like embossed plastic. A modest one with the right surface and a light that moves looks like paint. Oil painting has two kinds of depth:
- Relief, as in Rembrandt: the paint is raised and catches real light.
- Optical depth, as in van Eyck: light passes through thin glazes, bounces off the ground and comes back out, so color glows from inside.
Most painting apps attempt only the first.
What makes it read as oil
- A clear film over the color. Oil paint is pigment in linseed oil, so the highlight sits on a clear coat above the color. Fresh, fat paint is glossy; thin or dry paint goes matte, which painters call sinking in. Gloss that varies across the surface is what separates oil from plaster.
- Highlights that run along the stroke. Bristles leave parallel grooves, and a grooved surface stretches its highlight across them, as brushed metal does. It shows the direction the hand moved.
- Shade in the grooves. The edges of each stroke and its bristle grooves shade a little, so the paint reads as a surface.
- Glazes over dry paint. Treating each dry layer as the ground for the next makes a thin glaze glow over a light passage and almost vanish over a dark one.
- A light that moves. The lamp stays put in the room while the painting turns in your hands, so tilting the phone moves the light across the brushwork.
Conservators reach the same conclusion: they record paintings with Reflectance Transformation Imaging, many photos under different lights, precisely because the surface of the paint disappears in a flat photograph.
What Enogu does
Every stroke leaves a thin surface with its bristle grooves. The paint is lit as color under a clear film, with gloss that follows how much oil it holds, a highlight that runs along the grooves, and a little shade beside them. The light follows the phone's tilt. Dry the painting and new paint sits on top as a separate film, so glazes glow over what's beneath.
Not built: lighting from the real room or from where your head is, and sharing a painting that can still be relit.